Sorry, the current permissions prevented the action (Table data modify)

This is BC22.

I have made a table to store user login data from all companies. It is a simple table with two fields (field(1; "User ID"; Code[50]), field(2; "Last Login DateTime"; DateTime)).

The table has DataPerCompany = false; so it will record logins for any company.

Here is the code that is giving me the error:

[EventSubscriber(ObjectType::Codeunit, Codeunit::"System Initialization", 'OnAfterLogIn', '', false, false)]
    local procedure UpdateLastLoginInfo()
    var
        LoginHistory: Record csa_User_Login_History;
        lastLoginDuration: Duration;
    begin
        if UserId <> 'SYSTEM' then
            if LoginHistory.Get(UserId) then begin
                lastLoginDuration := CurrentDateTime - LoginHistory."Last Login DateTime";
                if (lastLoginDuration > (5 * 60 * 1000)) then begin
                    LoginHistory."Last Login DateTime" := CurrentDateTime;
                    LoginHistory.Modify(false); <------ [b]this line right here errors out[/b]
                end;
            end
            else begin
                LoginHistory.Init();
                LoginHistory."User ID" := UserId;
                LoginHistory."Last Login DateTime" := CurrentDateTime;
                LoginHistory.Insert();
            end;
    end;

The debugger will randomly error out on the LoginHistory.Modify(False) line with the message (visible only from the event viewer, it doesn't actually show up in the client):

Error Code:18023831
Sorry, the current permissions prevented the action. (TableData csa_User_Login_History User Login History Modify: Chase Base Application)

the codeunit has Permissions = tabledata "csa_User_Login_History" = RIMD;

My thinking is it's got something to do with it being a multi-company table, and lacking permissions to modify it in the other companies.

Does anyone have any ideas? It's really annoying to get a breakpoint error randomly.