Why is hidden column still shown visible in Customize Page?

lvanvugt
lvanvugt Member Posts: 774
edited 2011-09-23 in NAV Three Tier
Did you ever notice this?
When you dynamically hide a column like described in various post to be found here or here the column will indeed be hidden, but if you have a look at the Choose colums section on Customize This Page the column will be shown in the list of visible columns. And when you select the column name the Remove button is disabled.
Wouldn't it have been more logic that it was moved to the left in the list of available columns and disable the Add button?
Luc van Vugt, fluxxus.nl
Never stop learning
Van Vugt's dynamiXs
Dutch Dynamics Community

Answers

  • Troubles_In_Paradise
    Troubles_In_Paradise Member Posts: 588
    lvanvugt wrote:
    Wouldn't it have been more logic that it was moved to the left in the list of available columns and disable the Add button?

    I think would depend on what you obtain when you dynamic hide the column.
    In other words:
    Column must be visible -> on right and you couldn't remove it
    Coumn mustn't be visible -> on left and you couldn't add it

    In my humble opinion.
    ~Rik~
    It works as expected... More or Less...
  • lvanvugt
    lvanvugt Member Posts: 774
    True, but as an end-user I think it's strange to see the column shown on the right, but you do not see it on the page.
    Luc van Vugt, fluxxus.nl
    Never stop learning
    Van Vugt's dynamiXs
    Dutch Dynamics Community
  • Troubles_In_Paradise
    Troubles_In_Paradise Member Posts: 588
    lvanvugt wrote:
    True, but as an end-user I think it's strange to see the column shown on the right, but you do not see it on the page.
    (maybe I didn't got it right)

    You're right, in fact I thought that if column isn't shown on the page, I'd expect to find it on the left and I could not add it.
    I propose 2 cases...
    Troubles In Paradise wrote:
    Column must be visible -> on right and you couldn't remove it
    Coumn mustn't be visible -> on left and you couldn't add it
    ~Rik~
    It works as expected... More or Less...
  • Sog
    Sog Member Posts: 1,023
    It might be illogical for the end-user. But I think it makes sense from a developer pov.
    If its not visible and it's in the visible column, then you have a perfect check for enabling/disabling the remove button without creating extra variables and creating more overhead. I think the logical way would have a greater impact.
    And really, if users are complaining (not asking) about this, then they just are looking for reasons to piss off the helpdesk.
    |Pressing F1 is so much faster than opening your browser|
    |To-Increase|
  • TheDoubleH
    TheDoubleH Member Posts: 67
    This only happens when the VISIBLE property have an EXPRESSION.
    Kind Regards

    Henrik Helgesen,
    President | Helgesen Consulting
    about.me | LinkedIN
  • lvanvugt
    lvanvugt Member Posts: 774
    Henrik Helgesen wrote:
    This only happens when the VISIBLE property have an EXPRESSION.

    True! So the title of this post should have been Why is dynamically hidden column still shown visible in Customize Page?. :-$
    Luc van Vugt, fluxxus.nl
    Never stop learning
    Van Vugt's dynamiXs
    Dutch Dynamics Community

Categories